It's been quiet here for quite a while! We have therefore decided to archive the post. If this topic is still on your mind, feel free to start a new discussion.
Hello I was very happy about the idea of the insect hotel, which you can get for 40 collection points. The joy was soon gone when I took a closer look at the little house. Insect nesting aids made of pine wood do more harm than good. The insects injure their delicate wings on the fibrous softwood as soon as they reach the frayed entrance. I feel sorry for the animals. Another point of criticism is the material from New Zealand. The timber cultivation there offers no permanent habitat for animals. As soon as the planted trees are big enough, the whole forest is radically cleared. Production in China is the third negative point. Long transport routes are in contrast to a project that is supposed to support the environment. My insect hotel now hangs in the garden with stuffed boreholes. Gluing them shut would also be an option. Pine cones and bamboo tubes are ready for use : ) Conclusion: Brilliant idea, poorly researched, cheaply implemented. Suggestion for another time: Use local hardwood and have insect hotels made in protected Swiss workshops. Sand down frayed drill holes. I would be prepared to collect more points and/or pay an appropriate contribution for the additional financial outlay. Here is the link to a recommended homepage regarding insect nesting aids: https://www.naturgartenfreude.de/wildbienen/nisthilfen/bohrungen-im-hartholz/ Greetings, BeeWild
Hello BeeWild The possibilities of producing a large quantity of collection elements in Europe or even in Switzerland within a reasonable period of time and selling them to customers at an adequate trade-in price are limited. On the basis of a risk analysis, Migros checks the manufacturers concerned for compliance with minimum social requirements (in accordance with amfori BSCI). In addition, the collection elements are produced from sustainable raw materials. For example, all wood, cardboard and paper used for the Nature Heroes collection promotion is FSC certified. The insect hotel was developed in close consultation with internal and external Migros experts. The bamboo tubes are soft on the inside and therefore pose no danger to the insects. For the holes in the hardwood, care was taken to sand down the entrances so that there is no danger to the insects here either. In addition, the holes were drilled sufficiently deep and in different diameters so that they are as attractive as possible for different insect species. Best regards Peter
So experts, and why did the specialists put in pine cones where you really know it's nonsensical? ↵↵You say the bamboo tubes are soft on the inside? You can't use any with the "filling" still inside, only drilled out ones without the fluff. What then? Do you imagine that the maggots like to lie soft and cozy? ↵↵And pine wood is used. Resinous, unsuitable type of wood. Also softwood. Quote:↵"Softwoods (pine, spruce, fir, willow, poplar) are generally unsuitable. Drill holes in softwood tend to fray, and in damp weather the fibers inside the drill holes stand up and endanger the sensitive wings of the insects. With softwoods, there is also the problem of resinification."↵↵---------↵↵Must be great experts.↵Should change their subject area.↵↵-------↵↵↵After all, you admit that you are also interested in cheap procurement, that's honest.↵With a purchase price of at least (!) 800 Sfr (as 40 stickers at 20.-) a price per box of more than 4 francs would be fair😉↵↵↵And here is the observer:↵https://www.beobachter.ch/konsum/fur-dumm-verkauft/migros-sammelaktion-ein-weit-gereistes-bienenhotel
Does the insect hotel really not comply with animal welfare regulations? Then we won't get it. I'm also of the opinion that if you buy something for at least 800, it should be something useful. After all, Migros wants us to buy 2 crates for 800, which I personally think is a lot. Good to know, thanks for the info, we'll leave it at that. When the collection campaign started we thought it was great that Migros had finally come up with something nice, but apparently they can't manage that either. I'll contact the Swiss animal welfare organization tomorrow and then we'll know what's going on
In any case, it is not good, if any were to come to visit, they could be injured in the worst case.↵↵Other than what is being talked up here, the wood IS unsuitable and also not "hardwood" because fibers stick out when damp and injure the wings. Sanding or not, it tends to crack. The insects don't like that. ↵↵It remains to be seen whether the stalks are drilled out or not. If not, the larvae are at risk of being attacked by parasites that feel comfortable in the "padding" and of being attacked by mold, as the inner part is naturally prone to this.↵↵The pine cones are nonsense, which insect should be attracted? Hopefully not "earwigs", otherwise they would have a drive-in fast food store with the other insects and larvae. Seriously, what's the point of these pine cones other than to fill in a large area quickly and cheaply without much effort and "prettily" ↵↵And last but not least, wood from one place halfway around the world and then back to Switzerland? *just roll your eyes*↵↵↵As I said, whoever wants to get it is up to them. But it could even do some harm. And another thing: the protected species or those that you are trying to preserve don't even come to a hotel like this. One less🤭
Thank you for now. In any case, I'll find out tomorrow from animal welfare what Migros is trying to sell us as a super hit, because we don't want to be given or pay for crap that's included in the 800 euro purchase price. I think that you can always find an expert for some nonsense Apparently Migros has also found experts. Luckily we haven't picked it up yet, the collection campaign has been extended - presumably nobody wants the crap
In any case, it is not good, if any were to come to visit, they could be injured in the worst case.↵↵Other than what is being talked up here, the wood IS unsuitable and also not "hardwood" because fibers stick out when damp and injure the wings. Sanding or not, it tends to crack. The insects don't like that. ↵↵It remains to be seen whether the stalks are drilled out or not. If not, the larvae are at risk of being attacked by parasites that feel comfortable in the "padding" and of being attacked by mold, as the inner part is naturally prone to this.↵↵The pine cones are nonsense, which insect should be attracted? Hopefully not "earwigs", otherwise they would have a drive-in fast food store with the other insects and larvae. Seriously, what's the point of these pine cones other than to fill in a large area quickly and cheaply without much effort and "prettily" ↵↵And last but not least, wood from one place halfway around the world and then back to Switzerland? *just roll your eyes*↵↵↵As I said, whoever wants to get it is up to them. But it could even do some harm. And another thing: the protected species or those that you are trying to preserve don't even come to a hotel like this. One less🤭
Can you perhaps also tell us what the catch is with the other things that Migros wants to sell us? Garden tools etc.. Maybe child labor or violent? or something else we're not supposed to know about?
I completely agree with you! One possibility would also be for Migros to run higher quality collection campaigns. Bee hotel ok, but a really good one! In concrete terms, that means: instead of 3 cheap and worthless Manias, 1 good, ecological and fairly produced Mania! That would be the solution. And I know so many Migros families who feel the same way as I do.
Hi BeeWild, I came across your post because I wanted to complain about exactly the same thing. Migros meant well, but didn't question it enough and the customer is misled by the FSC label. What's more, the wood in these huts may have been gasified to prevent the introduction of vermin. This is a common procedure and is carried out in containers in which the wood is transported. It makes you wonder whether this is good for the insects. I have three of these little houses, have sanded the drill holes to a fine finish and, surprisingly, not a single insect goes into these holes, but the bamboo tubes are actively used. So, as I said, well meant, but questionable. Thank you for raising this issue, Migiliebe
Hi BeeWild, I came across your post because I wanted to complain about exactly the same thing. Migros meant well, but didn't question it enough and the customer is misled by the FSC label. What's more, the wood in these huts may have been gasified to prevent the introduction of vermin. This is a common procedure and is carried out in containers in which the wood is transported. It makes you wonder whether this is good for the insects. I have three of these little houses, have sanded the drill holes to a fine finish and, surprisingly, not a single insect goes into these holes, but the bamboo tubes are actively used. So, as I said, well meant, but questionable. Thank you for raising this issue, Migiliebe
So our little bees didn't complain about the hotel, but took to it straight away. And it was not apparent that any of them had been harmed. However, only one hole was used. The bamboo tubes were much more popular.
Ohh sustainable, it comes from China! And the wood from New Zealand is scandalous! As if wood wouldn't grow back there and transportation is absolutely no disgrace! Should a workshop for the disabled do the work here? is that more sustainable? international trade! Co2 madness or what? So ecologists should think about what happens to nature when you reduce Co2! Have you watched with a magnifying glass how they hurt their wings? I don't think so, make a video about it! I don't mind if robots do it instead of the Chinese! I wouldn't mind that either, but people would howl again! And fusion generators as an energy source for all I care! But you can't trust people to do that! And then? Crude oil is needed for various plastics one way or another, so a small proportion of it is also used for fuel! Now come on, oh no, plastics are sooo bad! Yes, it is, especially in the south, where most of it ends up in the sea because they've been playing around and don't have proper incineration! I'm just sick of professors who want to produce everything in Switzerland! Wake up! The majority of products come from abroad! That's okay, the problems are somewhere else in terms of progress, logistics etc. But that's too high for most people because they live in the past! edit: - 2 words that are not understood.
Ohh sustainable, it comes from China! And the wood from New Zealand is scandalous! As if wood wouldn't grow back there and transportation is absolutely no disgrace! Should a workshop for the disabled do the work here? is that more sustainable? international trade! Co2 madness or what? So ecologists should think about what happens to nature when you reduce Co2! Have you watched with a magnifying glass how they hurt their wings? I don't think so, make a video about it! I don't mind if robots do it instead of the Chinese! I wouldn't mind that either, but people would howl again! And fusion generators as an energy source for all I care! But you can't trust people to do that! And then? Crude oil is needed for various plastics one way or another, so a small proportion of it is also used for fuel! Now come on, oh no, plastics are sooo bad! Yes, it is, especially in the south, where most of it ends up in the sea because they've been playing around and don't have proper incineration! I'm just sick of professors who want to produce everything in Switzerland! Wake up! The majority of products come from abroad! That's okay, the problems are somewhere else in terms of progress, logistics etc. But that's too high for most people because they live in the past! edit: - 2 words that are not understood.
Okaaay, maybe you can do it properly? Or what's got into you?
Okaaay, maybe you can do it properly? Or what's got into you?
Why? Problems? That's decent! Your comment, on the other hand, is not decent! Topics like this get on my nerves! I only came across it because an article was in 20Minuten! 1000 times shared, the comment was PRAISED! That provokes me to express part of my opinion! Migro bashing with something like that! there are whole other points where bashing would be necessary! But typical comments like yours only make me aggressive! If the answer does not fit, report me and if the moderator does not like it, he can say something! My answer is justified in my opinion! It is my opinion, including certain extremes that I see as justified!
