It's been quiet here for quite a while! We have therefore decided to archive the post. If this topic is still on your mind, feel free to start a new discussion.

Guest
Dear Migros
Palm oil and its impact on the environment has been an issue in my family for some time. At first we thought it was in Nutella. We were almost desperate to find an alternative. The next shocking discovery we made was on the sweets shelf. Almost all of them contain palm oil. Even the ones labeled organic. And it goes on! The oil is also in soy cream and cake batter...
I don't understand the world anymore. Why can't you at least do without it in products developed by Migros? Palm oil is extremely harmful to our planet because rainforest is cleared for it. I don't think anyone wants to be responsible for this when they buy a product, and Migros could create a clear market advantage for itself if it actively took action against palm oil.
Hello everyone
I am happy to pass on some detailed feedback from our sustainability officer:
"On the subject of butter as a substitute for palm oil, we would like to point out that it is a question of technological and sensory properties, which means that palm oil can only be replaced by butter to a limited extent. From a health point of view, butter is no better than palm oil. For comparison: palm oil contains less saturated fatty acids overall than butter. The proportion of cholesterol-increasing fatty acids (lauric, myristic and palmitic acid) is about the same.
Palm oil also has many advantages that are appreciated in the food industry. This is because palm oil is already solid at room temperature (in contrast to olive oil, rapeseed oil, etc.) and therefore does not need to be hardened. This is an advantage in production, as incomplete hardening produces the undesirable trans fatty acids.
In order to replace palm oil, the recipes of many products would have to be changed, which would not always be to the benefit of the product or is hardly possible for some products.
If palm oil is replaced and another oil is used instead, we are confronted with the same problems. Palm oil has the highest productivity per unit area. If palm oil were to be replaced by another oil or fat, the available land would only become even scarcer, as a much larger area would be required for the same amount of the raw material. This would further increase the pressure on the rainforest and other natural areas worthy of protection. Animal fats, on the other hand, have a much worse impact on the environment, climate and health than vegetable oils and fats."
Best wishes and have a nice afternoon, Nicole
Hi Nicole_Migros,
I can understand these arguments and I believe Migros too!
But I must add one thing!
There is no substitute for butter in terms of taste!
When it comes to taste and fineness, nothing beats butter!
You probably don't have to be of a certain age to believe all these fairy tales you're told to write here. Pssst... I'll let you in on a secret: there was a time (not so long ago) when palm oil was unknown. And - wonder of wonders - we already had all these treats back then, and they were no worse than they are today. Just perhaps a little less long-lasting.
So in order to replace palm oil with butter, you would have to make extensive changes to the recipes? It brings tears to my eyes. Was it just as bad when the original recipes had to be adapted to palm oil? So please stop making fun of us!
And hey, please don't spread the word: the competition has palm oil-free Christmas cookies (that's not possible, how do they do it???). I'm happy to pay the moderate surcharge. Thank you and goodbye!
@Federwolke
I completely agree with you...
Butter instead of palm oil: Bahlsen switches production for Eastern Europe
21.07.2017 (APA)
Following fierce criticism from Eastern Europe, cookie manufacturer Bahlsen will use the original German recipe for all its products there in future.
The German cookie company Bahlsen is now also producing its butter cookies for Eastern Europe according to the German recipe - i.e. exclusively with butter and without palm oil. The company announced on Friday that this will standardize the recipe for all products - if this was not already the case - throughout Europe. In doing so, Bahlsen was "responding to the wishes of consumers", said a spokeswoman.
Source:
https://diepresse.com/home/wirtschaft/verbraucher/5256215/Butter-statt-Palmoel_Bahlsen-stellt-Produktion-fuer-Osteuropa-um
The above-mentioned article is legally cited with reference to the source, as provided for in Art. 28 CopA.

Guest
If you read the whole article, it seems to have little to do with the usual"palm oil is bad because of the rainforest and sustainability and is really great anyway", but simply with the fact that butteralso belongs in a butter cookie- purely for reasons of taste!
At some point, I'm sure someone will come up with the idea of making a shortbread without butter. I can imagine that if the manufacturer used palm oil for this, he would be shouted down by some people here. If, on the other hand, he poured in organic rapeseed oil and soy milk and marketed the whole thing as a 'vegan plait', he would be celebrated for it. I wouldn't like either. Of course, butter (and milk) should be used in a butter plait, and not too little of it. When I bake it myself, I use at least 200g of butter (approx. 1 'Mödeli') per 1kg of flour, even if most recipes call for less. Why? It tastes better to me.
Wherever fat is not only present in small quantities as a flavor carrier, but dominates the taste of the end product, butter must of course be used. But this is completely independent of the sustainability debate. As the Emperor said:"There is no substitute for butter in terms of taste!"
I would also welcome it if Migros got more involved in the palm oil issue. Migros, you could be a pioneer! do something

Guest
Hello Nicole,
Regarding butter: That may be partly true. But the main argument is probably the price. Butter is more expensive and you would have to reduce your margin.
On the hardening of vegetable oils: Today, they can be totally hydrogenated, so no longer partially hydrogenated. This means that trans fatty acids are no longer produced. Of course you have to communicate this. But isn't it worth it if you want to praise sustainability?
Here are the substitutes: Palm fat: there are alternatives.
Regarding the area: sunflower and rapeseed oil does not have to be grown in the tropics. The WWF study "On the oil trail" clearly states that there are wastelands where these crops could be grown without irreversibly destroying biologically valuable rainforest.
As Bread for All points out with various examples, those affected in the countries where the oil is grown argue that they should not consume RSPO palm oil either, because there is no difference on the ground to the non-certified plantations. The land rights problems, for example, remain exactly the same.
Migros knows this! But it is stubborn when it comes to communication and implementation. If RSPO would allow it, you could at least make a list of the products where you have converted. But RSPO forbids it. How can you be a member?

Guest
With regard to the whole palm oil story, I simply ask myself: What was needed when palm oil was not yet available in such large quantities? Were there no confectionery, spaetzli or other products that are made with palm oil today?
And the justification strategy of Migros - and others - is simply disgusting!

Guest
Due to the enormous development in production, it is difficult to compare the products of the past with those of today.
Palm oil has various properties; e.g. it is creamy and viscous at room temperature (desired consistency), does not go rancid quickly (shelf life), has binding, emulsifying properties, is very economical to produce in relation to other oilseeds...
In the past, products were less mechanized and other techniques were used to achieve the properties of palm oil: e.g. hardening vegetable oils to influence the consistency; animal fats were also increasingly used.
There is no question that there is no other way, but I assume that palm oil is preferred because of its price.

Guest
The Bahlsen company has just withdrawn its confectionery with palm oil (due to loud protests) and is producing it with butter again. So I assume that it is also possible without palm oil.
On the other hand, the farmers on Borneo and the Pacific Islands are very pleased that they are constantly being dispossessed of their land so that palm oil can be produced. And don't tell me that palm oil can be produced sustainably.
No, it's our mutis who want to rake in more and more, even if it means destroying the land of the indigenous farmers. The mutis don't care what happens to the world as long as they can make their money. That's one of the things that annoys me about this tiresome palm oil story.